In an unfortunate double whammy of home maintenance woes, our washing machine quit just after the plumbing disaster we wrote about yesterday. We’d hoped the plumbing issue would be a simple, inexpensive repair, but fate had other plans—and then our washer decided it was time to retire.
The repair technician inspected the machine and found significant corrosion, rusted bolts, and a broken belt. He told us he could try a temporary fix for about $200, but he didn’t expect it to last and recommended not investing more money in that unit. Coming from the person who would have accepted the payment, that straightforward advice felt reassuring even if it wasn’t what we wanted to hear.
So we found ourselves dipping into our emergency fund, right after resolving the plumbing issue, to shop for a replacement washer and dryer. We briefly considered buying used from places like ReStore or Craigslist, but decided a reliable, longer-term solution was worth the investment. After researching online and checking a few big box stores, we went in person to compare options and test out features.
We had looked forward to upgrading our laundry appliances someday—imagining shiny, feature-rich machines—but we didn’t expect to be shopping in a hurry with piles of laundry building up. Thankfully, John’s parents let us use their washer for a few loads while we finalized our choice, which bought us time to research without letting the laundry situation spiral.
We’ve adopted a new appliance philosophy: this time we didn’t want to chase the lowest price. Instead, we focused on research, durability, and features we’d actually use, since we expect these machines to last for years. Our previous purchase was a great deal—nearly 50% off—but we sacrificed a few conveniences, like a digital remaining-time display, that we missed later on.
After a lot of discussion and reading reviews, we narrowed our priorities to a concise list of criteria to guide the search:
- Top-loading washer. We prefer not bending over as much and wanted a machine that avoids the mildew maintenance common to many front-loaders. Modern top-loaders are also available in high-efficiency models that close the gap in capacity, spin speed, and water use.
- Whirlpool or Maytag. Both brands are produced by Whirlpool Corporation, which built our previous sets and had a track record of reliability for us. Based on our research and reader feedback, these brands offered a promising balance of performance and repair costs.
- Ability to silence the end-of-cycle buzzer. Our current dryer has an alarm that can’t be disabled, making it difficult to run during a child’s nap. A quieter or silencing option was essential.
- Digital display. A cycle time countdown is a small convenience we missed from earlier machines and wanted this time around to know exactly how much time remained.
- Dryer with steam. Steam cycles sounded useful for freshening clothes and reducing wrinkles, and many reviews reported it as a feature they actually used.
Our initial favorites were a Whirlpool set and a nearly identical Maytag option. Both had strong ratings, similar capacity and Energy Star performance, and comparable pricing. Then we found a third pair at Home Depot—an entry that was a slight step down in washer volume (.3 cubic feet less) and had a simpler aesthetic but carried excellent reviews and a price saving of more than $130 for the pair.
We narrowed our shopping to Home Depot and Lowe’s, where we’ve had good luck with appliance pricing in the past. Both stores were running stackable promotions—each marking prices 10% below MSRP plus an additional 10%-off-appliances sale—and both offered free delivery and haul-away. They also honor an extra 5% savings for store credit card users, which we factored into the final price comparison.
Home Depot had the model in stock at a promotional price, while Lowe’s would need to special order it and could only apply a single discount. We showed Lowe’s the Home Depot pricing and they offered to price match, but ultimately we purchased through Home Depot because they had the unit on the floor, offered the combined discounts, and we preferred the salesperson’s help there.
To keep things organized, we made a straightforward cost comparison to confirm the savings and delivery options. That helped us feel confident that we weren’t overpaying just because we needed the machines sooner rather than waiting for a holiday sale.
Delivery was scheduled for later the same day, so we were excited to test the new washer and dryer as soon as they arrived. We also have plans to address the laundry nook floor—there are small pieces of old carpet hidden beneath the current units—so we’re cautiously hopeful that removing the old appliances won’t reveal any unpleasant surprises.
In the meantime, fingers crossed that our replacement machines perform well and that the little renovation under them is uneventful. After two maintenance headaches in quick succession, we’re ready for some peace of mind from these new, more reliable laundry appliances.
Psst—None of the links in this post are affiliate links. Also, your hair looks pretty and I like your smile.