Paint has been a continual learning experience at Casa Petersik. From painting all our trim with flat paint when we first moved in (definitely a mistake — semi-gloss is the better choice) to choosing a different color for every room (not the way to create flow in a small house), we’ve tried almost everything. Over nearly four years our walls have “evolved” as we discovered what we liked and what didn’t.
We created a simple floor plan to show three stages of our home’s color changes to illustrate that a house rarely comes together overnight. Often it takes testing, repainting, and small adjustments to arrive at a cohesive palette. Each change moves you closer to the home you want—sometimes a fresh coat of paint in one afternoon (and around $30 a room) can transform a space and make it feel deliberately styled instead of chaotic.
Here’s what we meant when we said we used nearly every color in the rainbow when we first moved in.
Color Scheme: THEN
We started with an orangey-yellow in the den, a pastel green in the living room, and a bright robin’s egg blue in the former dining room (now the third bedroom) and the half bath. Those choices made the house feel like a series of unrelated rooms instead of a unified home. Looking back, painting two of the smallest rooms in bold colors was odd—there was no cohesion or flow through the modest ranch layout.
Interestingly, the only color we used in more than one place then was the bold turquoise in the third bedroom and half bath. As we learned more, we prioritized continuity in a small house by repeating colors or shifting a shade lighter or darker to keep rooms related. We repeated the soft blue-gray from the bedroom in the kitchen while toning the rest of the house to creams, sandy tans, and soft gray-blues. The result felt varied and interesting without being chaotic.
Color Scheme: MIDPOINT
Only the master bedroom and the sunroom stayed the same during the transition from the initial scheme to the midpoint palette. The midpoint colors may not be dramatic, but they made the house feel larger, more connected, and more mature. We achieved a calm, toned-down whole-house palette, but still wanted more texture and subtle surprises—nothing high-contrast, just a few unexpected touches to keep things fresh.
Color Scheme: NOW
The final tweaks weren’t dramatic, but several small changes delivered big visual returns and consistently earn paint-color compliments:
1. We painted the ceiling in the blue-gray bedroom a softer blue-green to create a dreamy, enveloping feel that beats a plain white ceiling.
2. In the half bath we painted tone-on-tone horizontal stripes in an evening and for under five dollars—one of the best time and money investments we’ve made.
3. We repainted the full bathroom from the living room/guest bedroom color to a soft khaki green. Since these rooms are close to each other, this added healthy variation to a layout that had previously felt too tan. We even carried the wall color onto the ceiling for a seamless effect.
4. For the nursery we chose a cheerful pear for the walls and a soft aqua for the ceiling. The blue ceiling links visually to the bedroom and kitchen, while the green walls tie to the nearby khaki bathroom and other green accents throughout the house.
We’re not finished. Homeownership is ongoing, and next up we plan to eliminate stark white ceilings. Painting ceilings in a lighter tone of the wall color, the exact wall hue when appropriate, or a complementary tint will help ceilings feel higher and better integrated into the palette. For example, we’d love to paint the tan sunroom ceiling sky blue to make it feel intentional and cohesive.
Below is a snapshot of our current paint choices (so you can see where we landed):
- Bedroom: Glidden Gentle Tide (walls) and Glidden Cool Cucumber (ceiling)
- Second Bedroom: Glidden Sand White
- Full Bathroom: Benjamin Moore Dune Grass (color matched to Olympic Premium No-VOC)
- Nursery: Mythic Autumn Bloom (walls) and Mythic Adanna Aire (ceiling)
- Living Room: Glidden Sand White
- Kitchen: Glidden Gentle Tide
- Den: Glidden Water Chestnut (fireplace accent wall) and Glidden Wishes (other walls)
- Laundry Nook: Glidden Wishes
- Half Bathroom: Glidden Wishes (walls) and Valspar Honeymilk (stripes and ceiling)
- Sunroom: Glidden Water Chestnut
- Trim & Interior Doors: Freshaire No-VOC stock white semi-gloss
Note: Some Glidden color names have changed or are no longer available; many stores can match formulas. Glidden’s Wishes is now called Eloquent Ivory. Benjamin Moore’s Quiet Moments is similar to Glidden Gentle Tide, and Benjamin Moore Ashen Tan is close to Glidden Sand White.
Here are the key lessons we learned along the way to help you choose a color palette that works in your home:
- Check color samples in morning, afternoon, and evening light to make sure a shade doesn’t shift from serene to unpleasant as the sun changes.
- Colors look different in different spaces and under different lighting. Always take paint chips home and tape them to the intended wall—don’t rely on how a color appears in a store or magazine.
- View paint swatches on the same plane they’ll occupy—tape them on the wall if you’re painting walls, or on the ceiling if you’re painting above.
- Compare a few chips side by side to eliminate options that read too yellow or too pink compared with others.
- We usually pick colors from the lower part of the swatch because lighter tones make a small house feel airier and larger.
- Neutrals can be anything but boring when paired with crisp white trim and layered furnishings, accessories, and textiles.
- Repeat colors across multiple spaces to create cohesion. We use about 80% of our colors in at least two rooms, which builds a layered, serene look.
- If you don’t want exact repetition, shift one tone lighter or darker so rooms feel related but distinct.
- Lean into colors you naturally prefer—our favorites are green and blue—using muted variations combined with neutrals for a reliable formula.
- Keeping flooring and trim consistent throughout helps unify the whole house.
- Small consistent elements—like a green plant in each room or white frames—help tie different spaces together.
- Remember that neutrals include creams and light platinums, not just tans and beiges; these can feel fresh and sophisticated.
- Subtle accent walls are often more effective than high-contrast ones, which can interrupt visual flow and make spaces feel fragmented.
In short: we made mistakes, learned, and repainted a room or two to get things right. Paint is the cheapest mistake you can make—don’t be paralyzed by indecision. Dive in: you’ll either love the outcome or learn what to avoid next time, and the cost of a repaint is small compared to the payoff. Happy painting!
Update – Want to know where something in our house came from or what paint we used? Click the button below to shop our house.
