How to Paint Metal Cups Into Two-Tone Votive Holders

When we found these small metal cups at Goodwill for $1.50 each (you might have seen them in our recent Halloween post) we decided they were perfect for a quick spray-paint refresh. We liked the little cut-out shape and already had yellow and white spray paint on hand from previous projects, so we jumped right in.

Small metal cups after spray painting

The plan was simple: make the inside of each cup yellow and the outside white for a clean two-tone effect. At first we considered painting the whole cup white, masking the rim, and then spraying yellow inside. We worried, however, that masking might pull fresh paint or make it difficult to reach the interior. Instead we started by spraying the inside with yellow—accepting that a little overspray on the exterior was inevitable:

Yellow sprayed inside of metal cup

Rather than use painter’s tape, we rolled a sheet of white paper and slipped it into each cup to protect the yellow interior while we sprayed the outside white. The paper fit easily and made covering the interior quick and mess-free.

Paper rolled and inserted into cup before spray painting

After spraying the exterior white and letting it dry, the cups started to look exactly like we’d imagined:

Cups after white spray on the outside

We didn’t know for sure how well the paper shield would work, so we were thrilled when we removed the rolled paper and saw a nearly perfect two-tone finish:

Nearly perfect two-tone finish revealed

The whole process was fast — the actual painting took only a few minutes. We did allow about five hours of drying time after the yellow coat before inserting the white paper and spraying the exterior, which helped prevent any smudging or peeling.

Finished two-tone metal cups

These cups are perfect for flameless candles: the yellow interiors glow warmly when a battery-operated candle is placed inside, but without any flame risk. That makes them a safe, pretty accent for shelves, mantels, or a centerpiece.

Flameless candle glowing inside painted cup

What about you? Have you tried a two-tone spray-paint finish on found objects lately? And do you use flameless candles in your decorating, or do you prefer the real thing? For small projects like this, battery-operated candles are convenient and safe—and they let the painted interiors really shine.