This all began with a simple goal: we wanted one of those charming “Historic District” plaques for our beach house. Spoiler alert: we got one — and a matching plaque for the duplex. Along the way we became amateur sleuths, budding history buffs, and, unsurprisingly, people who decided to repaint a front door. Here’s the story, a small porch update, and practical tips for researching the history of your own home.
After we bought our beach house three years ago, we admired the official Cape Charles Historic District plaque on our neighbor’s home. For a while we assumed that plaques were only issued to houses restored to strict historic standards — the kind of homes that still had original wood windows and original exterior elements. While we preserved many original features where possible — the front doors, corbels and brackets, stained glass, and the duplex’s unique diamond window grid (which we reproduced to match the original) — other elements had been replaced long before we arrived, such as rotten siding we swapped for hardiplank and vinyl windows installed decades earlier.
It turned out any home within the town’s historic district is eligible for the plaque — you just need to document an approximate construction date and pay $30 for production. Sign us up.
The pink house’s date seemed straightforward: the listing we saw when we bought it listed 1920, and our neighbor’s plaque also read 1920. The duplex, however, was a mystery. Its design is unique on the street and many original features had been removed or altered over the years. People guessed wildly — from the 1890s to the 1950s — based on different architectural cues and renovation discoveries.
A helpful town employee directed us to historic tax records that had been digitized and posted online. Those records can be confusing at first, but once you identify your lot number you can find the earliest recorded taxable structure — the first time a “value of buildings on lot” shows up. Initially we thought the pink house dated back to 1915, but further review revealed both the pink house and the duplex appeared on the 1910 tax records. That prompted deeper digging.
We discovered digitized Sanborn Maps — old fire insurance maps from the 19th and 20th centuries — on the town website and on the Library of Congress site. Comparing maps from different years helped narrow construction windows. The maps showed the beach house was built between 1898 and 1904, while the duplex was constructed between 1904 and 1910. For example, a lot that was empty on the 1904 map clearly contained a house on the 1910 map, so we knew the building was added between those years.
In the case of the beach house, earlier maps from 1898 showed small structures on the lot that appeared to be sheds or outbuildings, not the main house. The 1904 map showed a building matching the current house’s shape and size. Presenting these maps to the town staff provided sufficient evidence to order the plaques: 1904 for the beach house and 1910 for the duplex. For $60 and a few days’ wait, the plaques arrived.
We attached the beach house plaque using four screws and clear caulk to keep moisture out, placing it in a location similar to our neighbor’s. The duplex presented a placement challenge because of its symmetry and having only one plaque. After trying several locations, we mounted it along the foundation, similar to a building’s cornerstone. We used outdoor adhesive to secure it; the plaques are lightweight, weatherproof foam-core and have held up well.
Installing the plaques also nudged Sherry to finally repaint the beach house front door. It’s the original wood door; two years earlier we had gel-stained it to mask wear, but it looked too dark and shiny and didn’t let the door’s character show. We wanted a subtle, period-appropriate color that would anchor the house’s historic feel. After sampling swatches we chose True Value Mountain Gray. The lighter tone reveals details like the mail slot, centered doorbell, and old hardware, making the door’s original character more pronounced.
Our photographer friends, who live one block away, even made sure to include the 1904 sign in our family photos. That made us happy.
Becoming mini history detectives made us eager to find out more. We already knew a notable 1936 incident had happened on our street, but we explored other sources to learn more about our homes’ pasts and how to do similar research yourself.
Visit Any Local Museums
Local museums are great resources. The town museum had binders, postcards, photos, and letters. Although we didn’t find a dated photo of our exact house, we located an old postcard of the houses across the street. Standing in the same spot and comparing then-and-now views was surprisingly moving.
The museum staff mentioned there might be additional photo archives nearby, so we plan to return and keep searching. If you’re hunting for details on your house, local museums are an excellent place to start.
Visit Your Local Library
Libraries often hold local history collections, yearbooks, and old newspapers. At the Cape Charles Public Library we found fascinating high school yearbooks and other local history books with timelines and photos that help place changes in context, even if they don’t show your specific street.
Visit Your Local Courthouse
County courthouses can hold long runs of property and tax records. Our county claims some of the oldest continuous court records in the U.S., and we were able to access physical tax and property sale records going back centuries. Those handwritten records revealed past owners, sale prices, and other transactions. One surprising detail we found: the duplex sold at auction in 1937 for $1,100. Searching courthouse archives can uncover surprising and useful facts about a home’s chain of ownership.
Use the Internet
Online resources make research faster. Once you have past owners’ names from courthouse records, a simple web search or genealogy service can provide context — census records, obituaries, and more. Searching for “Historic photos” of your town, checking digitized map collections, or browsing image sites and social platforms can reveal old photos or clues. For us, Sanborn Maps and digitized tax records were key for narrowing construction dates, while Pinterest and online photo collections helped us find neighborhood images and restoration inspiration.
We haven’t finished hunting for every photograph or document related to our street, but getting the historic plaques felt like a satisfying milestone. If you want to research your own house, start at town hall or the local historical society, compare old maps, explore museum and library collections, and check courthouse records. It’s a rewarding way to connect with the past and uncover unexpected stories hidden in the walls around you.
For more posts like this, check our archives where we share deep-dive history posts, stories about meeting original owners, and other house-related discoveries.
*This post contains affiliate links*